The Subscription Trap: ROSCA, the Revived Click-to-Cancel Rule, and Dark Patterns Enforcement in 2026
On-Demand · 2 CLE credits · November 16, 2026, 12:00 PM ET
Subscription marketing is the FTC’s most active enforcement front, and class counsel are following. Learn to apply ROSCA and state auto-renewal laws, structure free trials and cancellation flows that survive scrutiny, spot dark patterns, and audit enrollment, billing, and cancellation UX.
The Cancel Button Is Now the Evidence
Subscription enforcement is no longer a settled playbook. The FTC revived Click-to-Cancel rulemaking after the Eighth Circuit's 2025 vacatur and kept up a wave of ROSCA actions. State attorneys general layered on auto-renewal statutes and "dark patterns" theories. Plaintiffs' firms are converting the same playbook into class actions.
The exposure is concrete. Bury a renewal term and ROSCA's clear-and-conspicuous standard is breached. Skip express informed consent and the enrollment fails. Add cancellation friction and the "simple mechanism" standard is violated. Miss California or New York reminder notices and a multistate AG action follows. Pre-check a box or drip-price and the interface itself becomes the exhibit.
This two-session program gives attorneys advising any recurring-revenue business a working map of where enforcement is heading. Attendees leave with ROSCA disclosure, consent, and cancellation standards as applied in recent FTC actions and the state auto-renewal patchwork. They gain conversion structures for free trials and "save" offers, the FTC's dark patterns taxonomy, and defenses against the class-action pivot. They leave with a step-by-step audit framework for enrollment, billing, and cancellation UX.
Key topics
- Click-to-Cancel After Vacatur: Know what the Eighth Circuit vacatur and the FTC’s 2026 revival leave enforceable now, and what is coming next.
- ROSCA Compliance in Practice: Apply clear-and-conspicuous disclosure, express informed consent, and the “simple mechanism” cancellation standard as recent FTC actions read them.
- State Auto-Renewal Overlay: Navigate California, New York, and the expanding patchwork of reminder notices, renewal-term disclosures, and multistate AG enforcement.
- Conversions and Consent Orders: Structure free trials, upsells, and “save” offers that survive scrutiny, guided by what 2025–2026 consent orders require and the redress and civil-penalty exposure.
- Dark Patterns as Evidence: Dark Patterns as Evidence Recognize confirmshaming, pre-checked boxes, drip pricing, obstruction, and AI-personalized offers that cross into deception, and see how screenshots, click-path analytics, and A/B test records are used against companies.
- Class Actions and the Audit: Anticipate how plaintiffs’ counsel repurpose FTC and state AG theories, the defenses that are working, and a step-by-step audit of enrollment, billing, and cancellation UX that builds the record first.
Agenda
- The Rules of the Recurring Charge: ROSCA, State Auto-Renewal Laws, and the Click-to-Cancel Revival
- Dark Patterns on Trial: Interface Design as a Consumer-Protection Violation
Faculty
- Linda A. Goldstein, CM Law
- Andrew Lustigman, Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP
State accreditation
- AK: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AL: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- AR: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- AZ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- CO: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- CT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- DC: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- DE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- FL: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 General Hours
- GA: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- HI: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- IA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ID: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- IL: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- IN: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- KS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 Substantive
- KY: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- LA: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MA: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- ME: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MI: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- MN: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MO: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2.4 General
- MS: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- MT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- ND: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NE: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NH: Approved for CLE Credits, 120 General minutes
- NJ: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- NM: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- NV: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- NY: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- OH: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- OK: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- OR: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- PA: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- RI: Pending CLE Approval, 2.5 General
- SC: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- SD: No MCLE Required, 2 CLE Hour(s)
- TN: Approved for Self-Study Credits, 2 General
- TX: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- UT: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- VA: Not Eligible, 2 General Hours
- VT: Approved for CLE Credits, 2 General
- WA: Approved via Attorney Submission, 2 Law & Legal Hours
- WI: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General
- WV: Pending CLE Approval, 2.4 General
- WY: Pending CLE Approval, 2 General