Policyholder Property Bad Faith: Discovering the Insurer’s Claims-Reduction Program and Proving It at Trial

Michael J. Bidart
Michael J. Bidart | Shernoff Bidart Echeverria LLP

Michael J. Bidart is the Managing Partner of Shernoff Bidart Echeverria LLP, where he leads the firm's HMO Litigation and Property/Casualty Departments and devotes his practice entirely to litigation. Since joining the firm in 1986, he has built its health insurance practice by successfully prosecuting bad faith disputes against insurers and HMOs.

Live Video-Broadcast: January 20, 2027

2 hour CLE

Tuition: $195.00
Subscribe to Federal Bar Association CLE Pass...
Co-Sponsored by myLawCLE
Get this course, plus over 1,000+ of live webinars.
Learn More
Training 5 or more people?

Sign-up for a law firm subscription plan and each attorney in the firm receives free access to all CLE Programs

Program Summary

 

Proving the Program, Not Just the Adjuster, Decided the Claim

Judge Sheperd's August 20, 2026 order in West v. State Farm, together with the Hursh record, shows how policyholders in property bad faith cases are proving that a denied or underpaid claim reflected an insurer-wide claims-reduction program, not one adjuster's error. Courts in both cases have ordered program documents de-designated. The fight now runs from first-set requests through the punitive damages instruction.

Ask only about your client's claim, and the individual-claim objection shuts the door on benchmark documents. Let a blanket designation stand, and the program record stays sealed. Notice a CEO without a personal-knowledge record, and the apex objection wins. Offer program evidence without tying it to your claim, and Campbell and Williams limit what the jury may punish.

Attendees walk out with sample requests, a motion outline, an exhibit matrix, a multistate chart of punitive caps and privilege rules, and a draft limiting instruction. It is practitioner judgment from a policyholder trial lawyer who has spent decades proving bad faith claims practices to juries.

Key topics to be discussed:

  • Program Vocabulary and First-Set Requests
    How to turn the carrier's own program and estimating terms into benchmark-targeted requests that survive the individual-claim objection.
  • Defeating Blanket Designations
    How the West and Hursh orders shape protective-order terms and the de-designation motion.
  • Executives and Consultants
    How to build the personal-knowledge record for executive depositions and enforce a subpoena on an out-of-state consultant.
  • The Program-to-Claim Tie
    How an exhibit matrix and locked designee definitions connect program documents to a single claim decision.
  • Statistics and Delay
    How to present program statistics under Rule 702 through party admissions and preserve the delay theory after post-suit payment.
  • Punitive Damages Within Campbell
    How to build a punitive record and limiting instruction under Campbell, Williams, Oklahoma's § 9.1, and Eddy.

This course is co-sponsored with myLawCLE.

Date / Time: January 20, 2027

  • 12:00 pm – 2:10 pm Eastern
  • 11:00 am – 1:10 pm Central
  • 10:00 am – 12:10 pm Mountain
  • 9:00 am – 11:10 am Pacific

Closed-captioning available

Speakers

Michael J. Bidart, Managing Partner | Shernoff Bidart Echeverria LLP

Michael J. Bidart is the Managing Partner of Shernoff Bidart Echeverria LLP, where he leads the firm’s HMO Litigation and Property/Casualty Departments and devotes his practice entirely to litigation. Since joining the firm in 1986, he has built its health insurance practice by successfully prosecuting bad faith disputes against insurers and HMOs. He is especially well suited to this program: decades of prosecuting bad faith cases against insurers, including Notrica v. State Compensation Insurance Fund, which produced a $20 million punitive award and an injunction rewriting the insurer’s claims estimating manual, and a landmark $120.5 million verdict against Aetna, bringing the perspective of a policyholder trial lawyer who has proved institutional claims practices to juries.

  • Education & Credentials

Mr. Bidart earned his J.D. from Pepperdine University School of Law in 1974 and his B.S. in Economics from California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, in 1971, receiving the Distinguished Alumnus Award from both. He is admitted before the California Supreme Court, the U.S. Supreme Court, the U.S. Court of Appeals, and all four federal district courts in California.

  • Recognition & Leadership

Mr. Bidart was named Trial Lawyer of the Year by the Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles (2015) and by CAL ABOTA (2011), and the Los Angeles Daily Journal has named him a Top 25 California Plaintiff Attorney and a Top Healthcare Attorney in California. He has been a Southern California Super Lawyers Top 100 attorney every year since 2004 and a Top 10 attorney since 2018, Best Lawyers’ Inland Empire Insurance Law Lawyer of the Year in 2014, 2017, 2021, and 2023 through 2026, and California Lawyer magazine has named him one of California’s 100 most influential lawyers.

  • Professional Involvement

Mr. Bidart is a Fellow of the American Board of Trial Advocates, the American College of Trial Lawyers, and the International Academy of Trial Lawyers. He has served on the Boards of Governors of the Consumer Attorneys of California and the Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles. A well-known lecturer and keynote speaker on bad faith insurance practices, he has been a featured speaker for The Rutter Group and the California Judges Association.

  • Experience

Mr. Bidart won a landmark $120.5 million verdict against Aetna in Goodrich v. Aetna, then the largest against an HMO, and in Notrica v. State Compensation Insurance Fund secured a $20 million punitive award and an injunction requiring the insurer to change the reserve standard in its claims estimating manual. In State Farm v. Superior Court, he helped establish that California’s unfair business practice statute applies to insurers, and he recovered more than $300 million for victims of the 1994 Northridge earthquake. His work has produced dozens of published opinions protecting insureds, including Minkler v. Safeco, and a $28 million verdict in the Rahm trial against Kaiser.

Agenda

SESSION 1 – Discovering the Insurer’s Claims-Reduction Program in Policyholder Property Bad Faith Cases | Michael J. Bidart | 12:00pm – 1:00pm

This session walks policyholder-side first-party property bad faith counsel through building discovery around a national carrier’s claims-reduction program, using the West and Hursh State Farm records. Attorneys will learn how to turn the carrier’s own program vocabulary into benchmark-targeted first-set requests, which estimating-platform and adjuster-level records to name, how to negotiate protective-order terms and bring a de-designation motion against blanket confidentiality designations, how to build the personal-knowledge record behind executive and corporate-designee depositions, and how to serve and enforce a non-party subpoena on an out-of-state consultant. Attendees will leave with sample requests, a motion outline, and a clear sense of the wording and timing that move these discovery fights.

BREAK | 1:00pm – 1:10pm

SESSION 2 – Proving Institutional Bad Faith and Punitive Damages with Insurer Program Documents at Trial | Michael J. Bidart | 1:10pm – 2:10pm

This session turns insurer program documents into trial proof that the program decided the client’s claim. Attorneys will learn how to build a program-to-claim exhibit matrix, lock designee definitions against the “accuracy and quality” defense, present statistics under Rule 702 through party admissions rather than industry headlines, preserve the delay theory after post-suit payment, and build a punitive damages record and limiting instruction that withstand State Farm v. Campbell and Philip Morris v. Williams, along with Oklahoma’s § 9.1 framework and the Eddy claim-file privilege limit. Attendees will leave with an exhibit matrix, a multistate chart of punitive caps and privilege rules, and a draft limiting instruction.

Credits

Alaska

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.
Alabama

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Arkansas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Arizona

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

California

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Colorado

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Connecticut

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

District of Columbia

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Delaware

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Florida

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 General Hours

Receive CLE credit in Florida via attorney submission.
Georgia

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Hawaii

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Iowa

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Idaho

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Illinois

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Indiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Kansas

Pending CLE Approval
2 Substantive

Kentucky

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Louisiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Massachusetts

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maryland

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maine

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Michigan

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Minnesota

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Missouri

Approved for CLE Credits
2.4 General

Mississippi

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Montana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Dakota

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14
Nebraska

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.
New Hampshire

Approved for CLE Credits
120 General minutes

As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.
New Jersey

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2
New Mexico

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Nevada

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

New York

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.
Ohio

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Oklahoma

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

Oregon

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Pennsylvania

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Rhode Island

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

South Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

South Dakota

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Tennessee

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Texas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Utah

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Virginia

Not Eligible
2 General Hours

Vermont

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Washington

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 Law & Legal Hours

Receive CLE credit in Washington via attorney submission.
Wisconsin

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

West Virginia

Pending CLE Approval
2.4 General

Wyoming

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

More CLE Webinars
Upcoming CLE Webinars
AI-Augmented Legal Workflows: A Map to Success
AI-Augmented Legal Workflows: A Map to Success Thu, November 19, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay
Using Adobe Acrobat’s AI Assistant for Legal
Using Adobe Acrobat’s AI Assistant for Legal Fri, November 20, 2026
Live Webcast
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition)
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition) Tue, November 24, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay
False Claims Act Hot Topics (2026 Edition)
False Claims Act Hot Topics (2026 Edition) Tue, December 1, 2026
Live Webcast
HIPAA Privacy, Security and AI – Oh My!
HIPAA Privacy, Security and AI – Oh My! Tue, December 1, 2026
Live Webcast