AI Prompts and Chat Logs in Civil Litigation: Protecting Yours, Pursuing Theirs

Ronaldo Rauseo-Ricupero
Matthew W. Costello
Leslie Hartford
Ronaldo Rauseo-Ricupero | Nixon Peabody LLP
Matthew W. Costello | Nixon Peabody LLP
Leslie Hartford | Nixon Peabody LLP

Live Video-Broadcast: December 17, 2026

2 hour CLE

Tuition: $195.00
Subscribe to Federal Bar Association CLE Pass...
Co-Sponsored by myLawCLE
Get this course, plus over 1,000+ of live webinars.
Learn More
Training 5 or more people?

Sign-up for a law firm subscription plan and each attorney in the firm receives free access to all CLE Programs

Program Summary

 

Your Client Asked ChatGPT First. Now the Other Side Wants the Chat

Clients and employees use ChatGPT, Copilot, Claude, Gemini, and AI notetakers to think through disputes, often before calling counsel. Litigants now seek those prompts and outputs through Rule 34 requests and provider subpoenas. Courts are only beginning to decide whether they are privileged, work product, or ordinary ESI. The answer turns on who prompted, whether counsel directed it, what tool was used, and what was shared.

Let a client use consumer Claude without counsel’s direction, and Heppner found the chats neither privileged nor work product. Rely on an implied “expert notes” agreement, and CLF v. Shell treated an expert’s prompts as discoverable methodology. Upload discovery material to consumer Claude, and Fry v. Fry denied sealing in part. Request every chat about the litigation, and Fontainebleau called it overbroad. File unverified AI citations, and the sanctions record grows.

You leave with client intake questions, litigation holds that reach AI accounts and notetakers, clause text for ESI protocols and protective orders, and a method for splitting requests, logging AI threads, and building the in camera package. Anticipated materials include a case law chart and a preservation checklist. This is litigator judgment on this year’s rulings, not doctrine a chatbot can recite.

Key topics to be discussed:

  • Facts That Decide Protection
    How who prompted, whether counsel directed the use, which tool was used, and what was shared decide protection under Heppner, Warner, Morgan, Shealy, Fontainebleau, and Tate.
  • Counseling and Preservation
    How intake questions, counsel-directed AI use, and litigation holds that reach enterprise accounts, consumer accounts, and AI notetakers protect your client before a dispute arises.
  • Protocols and Protective Orders
    How to handle AI at the Rule 26(f) conference, name and define excluded material after CLF v. Shell, and redline upload restrictions in protective orders.
  • Requests and Burden Records
    How to draft targeted requests and provider subpoenas, address AI use at depositions, and split an overbroad request while building the burden record.
  • Work Product, Waiver, Review
    How to argue Rule 26(b)(3)(A) protection for uninstructed employee AI use, treat waiver as disclosure to an adversary, log AI threads, and preserve Rule 72(a) objections and motions to quash.
  • Experts, Counsel, and Ethics
    How courts separate discoverable AI methodology and facts or data from protected drafts, and how Formal Opinion 512, Rule 11, and the sanctions record govern your own AI use.

This course is co-sponsored with myLawCLE.

Date / Time: December 17, 2026

  • 12:00 pm – 2:10 pm Eastern
  • 11:00 pm – 1:10 pm Central
  • 10:00 am – 12:10 pm Mountain
  • 9:00 am – 11:10 pm Pacific

Closed-captioning available

Speakers

Ronaldo Rauseo-Ricupero, Counsel | Nixon Peabody LLP

Ronaldo Rauseo-Ricupero chairs Nixon Peabody’s Electronic Discovery & Digital Evidence team, and he has written about and counseled clients on e-discovery at every stage, from retention and collection through production and motion practice. Based in the firm’s Boston office, he defends corporations and individuals in government investigations and the complex civil actions connected to them. He also defends plan sponsors and fiduciaries in ERISA litigation and maintains an active pro bono practice.

  • Education & Credentials

Rauseo-Ricupero received his J.D. from Boston College Law School and his B.A., cum laude, from Harvard College. He is admitted to practice in Massachusetts.

  • Recognition & Leadership

He has been selected for The Best Lawyers in America in Commercial Litigation each year since 2025. The Hispanic National Bar Association named him one of its Top Lawyers Under 40 in March 2020, and Super Lawyers recognized him as a Rising Star in white collar defense from 2013 through 2016. His pro bono work has earned the Adams Pro Bono Publico Award, the Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly Excellence in Pro Bono Award, and Nixon Peabody’s inaugural firmwide Pro Bono Attorney of the Year award.

  • Professional Involvement

He drafted the Massachusetts E-Discovery and Evidence treatise from 2013 to 2019 and co-authored “Chapter 19: Electronic Discovery” in the third and fourth editions of the Massachusetts Superior Court Practice Manual. He also co-authored “Bring Your Own Dilemmas—‘Custody’ in the Digital Age” in Financier Worldwide (2017), and he has spoken on third-party subpoena response at the National E-Discovery Leadership Institute (2016) and on the effect of new discovery rules at the Massachusetts Social Law Library (2015). He serves on the board of editors of the Boston Bar Journal and the board of the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts.

  • Experience

In litigation, Rauseo-Ricupero second-chaired a two-week trial that ended in a total defense verdict for a major energy company, argued and won a Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court case on accountant and auditor liability and represented an international construction client in a 40-day multiparty arbitration. His investigations work includes matters before the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office and the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Boston, as well as federal and state investigations of a national pharmaceutical company’s marketing and contracting.

He previously served as a special assistant district attorney in Middlesex County and as a special assistant attorney general. Earlier, he worked in the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia and in the chambers of U.S. District Judge Mark L. Wolf.

 

Matthew W. Costello, Counsel | Nixon Peabody LLP

Matthew W. Costello follows how technology and AI are changing litigation, and in April 2026 he discussed attorney-client privilege and AI use after United States v. Heppner in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly, including early client conversations about AI tools and the treatment of AI chat logs and prompts in discovery requests. He is counsel in Nixon Peabody’s Complex Commercial Disputes practice in Boston, where he litigates complex matters in state and federal courts and works with technology-enabled, responsible AI-assisted workflows. A central focus of his practice is defending ERISA class actions alleging breach of fiduciary duty over retirement plan investment options and administrative fees.

  • Education & Credentials

Costello earned his J.D., magna cum laude, from Suffolk University Law School, where he was Managing Editor of the Suffolk University Law Review, and his B.S., cum laude, from Fitchburg State University. He is admitted in Massachusetts and Rhode Island and before the U.S. Courts of Appeals for the First and Ninth Circuits and the U.S. District Courts for Massachusetts and Rhode Island.

  • Recognition & Leadership

Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly named him a 2026 Up & Coming Lawyer, and he was a 2026 Nixon Peabody Pro Bono Champion. He is recognized in Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch for Commercial Litigation for 2027 (listed since 2024) and was a Massachusetts Super Lawyers Rising Star from 2023 to 2025. He serves as Co-Chair and a Board Member of the Massachusetts LGBTQ Bar Association.

  • Professional Involvement

Costello serves on the Massachusetts Bar Association’s Complex Commercial Litigation Section Council and the Boston Bar Association’s Business & Commercial Litigation Steering Committee. His commentary has appeared in Law360, Bloomberg Law, and Corporate Counsel on Second Circuit securities pleading standards, a Third Circuit ERISA ruling, and FCRA standing, and he co-authored an article on attorneys’ fee practices in the Massachusetts Bar Association Section Review (2025).

  • Experience

Costello’s matters, including some handled at prior firms, include representing a financial services company in a data breach MDL in the District of Massachusetts. He obtained full dismissal of a securities class action against a Boston brewery, affirmed by the Second Circuit, and was a member of the defense teams in the ERISA class actions Sacerdote v. New York University (S.D.N.Y.), Kistler v. Stanley Black & Decker (D. Conn.), and Baker v. University of Vermont Medical Center (D. Vt.).

Before joining Nixon Peabody, he was a litigation associate at a boutique firm and at a top-50 Am Law firm. He clerked for Judge William E. Smith of the U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island and for Justice Gilbert V. Indeglia of the Rhode Island Supreme Court, and during law school he interned for Judge Timothy S. Hillman (D. Mass.) and the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Massachusetts.

 

Leslie Hartford, Counsel | Nixon Peabody LLP

Leslie Hartford is a litigator and Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) whose practice centers on data privacy litigation, trade secret litigation, and trademark and copyright enforcement. She helps clients prepare cybersecurity protocols and respond to cyber incidents, and she has handled the state and federal privacy litigation, including class actions, that can follow. In trade secret matters she has managed complex discovery, including sensitive disclosure processes for proprietary information. She practices in Nixon Peabody’s Boston office.

  • Education & Credentials

Hartford received her J.D. from Georgetown University Law Center and her B.A. from Duke University. She holds the CIPP/US certification and is admitted in Massachusetts and before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan.

  • Recognition & Leadership

Hartford was promoted to counsel at Nixon Peabody in January 2024. Her matters have drawn press coverage, including W.B. Mason’s trial victory in the Dairy Queen “Blizzard” trademark case (The Boston Globe, Law360, and Fox News) and the October 2025 dismissal of a proposed consumer class action against Paychex over a 2024 data breach (Bloomberg Law and Law360).

  • Professional Involvement

She has presented CLE programs on data protection and privacy trends at Nixon Peabody’s 2025 California MCLE seminar and on cyberattack response at its 2023 seminar, and she has delivered in-house counsel CLEs on cybersecurity and data privacy for a financial services client (2024) and on cybersecurity trends and ransomware risk for a healthcare client (2023). In May 2023 she appeared in “A Little Privacy Please,” a firm video on Italy’s ban of ChatGPT. She co-authored a June 2021 Intellectual Property & Technology Law Journal article on the TCPA after Facebook v. Duguid.

  • Experience

Hartford defended a healthcare client in a data breach class action through a favorable settlement and assisted a global manufacturer after a cyberattack with post-attack communications and class action defense, and she has negotiated resolutions of funds transfer fraud incidents. On the trade secret side, she defended a healthcare technology client in a suit that settled after the plaintiff dismissed multiple claims, and she protected a worldwide beverage manufacturer’s trade secrets and corporate opportunities against a start-up competitor.

She was on the team that won a complete defense verdict against trademark infringement, dilution, unfair competition, and deceptive trade practices claims, and she prepared a B2B office supplier for trial in the Dairy Queen “Blizzard” action in the District of Minnesota, including a successful motion to strike untimely evidence. She also helped defend a U.S. chemical startup through trial on claims of willful patent infringement involving catalyst technology.

Agenda

SESSION 1 – Before the Fight: Counseling, Preservation, and AI Terms in ESI Protocols and Protective Orders | Matthew W. Costello, Leslie Hartford & Ronaldo Rauseo-Ricupero | 12:00pm – 1:00pm

This session covers the work litigators should do before AI discovery disputes arise. It opens with a short case law map organized around the facts that drive outcomes, then covers the client conversation at intake, litigation holds that reach AI accounts and notetakers, and the Rule 26(f) decision whether to raise AI. The second half covers drafting exclusions after CLF v. Shell, redlining the opening protocol, the new rulings on uploading discovery material to AI tools, and how courts separate experts’ and counsel’s discoverable AI use from protected drafts.

BREAK | 1:00pm – 1:10pm

SESSION 2 – In the Fight: Requesting, Answering, and Litigating AI Chat Log Discovery | Matthew W. Costello, Leslie Hartford & Ronaldo Rauseo-Ricupero | 1:10pm – 2:10pm

This session covers AI chat log discovery once requests are served, from both sides. It opens with the requesting party: why AI chats can bear on intent, how to draft requests and provider subpoenas that survive overbreadth objections, and how to handle a witness using AI at a deposition. It then turns to the responding party: splitting the request, the burden record, the work product argument for a represented company’s employees after Fontainebleau, Shealy, Morgan, and Tate, waiver, logging, the in camera package, and the Rule 72(a) record. It closes with the ethics rules for lawyers’ own AI use.

Credits

Alaska

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.
Alabama

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Arkansas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Arizona

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

California

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Colorado

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Connecticut

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

District of Columbia

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Delaware

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Florida

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Georgia

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Hawaii

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Iowa

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Idaho

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Illinois

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Indiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Kansas

Pending CLE Approval
2 Substantive

Kentucky

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Louisiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Massachusetts

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maryland

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maine

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Michigan

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Minnesota

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Missouri

Approved for CLE Credits
2.4 General

Mississippi

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Montana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Dakota

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14
Nebraska

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.
New Hampshire

Approved for CLE Credits
120 General minutes

As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.
New Jersey

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2
New Mexico

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Nevada

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

New York

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.
Ohio

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Oklahoma

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

Oregon

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Pennsylvania

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Rhode Island

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

South Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

South Dakota

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Tennessee

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Texas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Utah

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Virginia

Not Eligible
2 General Hours

Vermont

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Washington

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 Law & Legal Hours

Receive CLE credit in Washington via attorney submission.
Wisconsin

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

West Virginia

Pending CLE Approval
2.4 General

Wyoming

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

More CLE Webinars
Upcoming CLE Webinars
AI-Augmented Legal Workflows: A Map to Success
AI-Augmented Legal Workflows: A Map to Success Thu, November 19, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay
Using Adobe Acrobat’s AI Assistant for Legal
Using Adobe Acrobat’s AI Assistant for Legal Fri, November 20, 2026
Live Webcast
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition)
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition) Tue, November 24, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay