ERISA Disability Claimant Counsel: Keeping Benefits Past the 24-Month Mental-Health Limitation with Physical-Causation Proof

Mark D. DeBofsky
Mark D. DeBofsky | DeBofsky Law, Ltd

Mark D. DeBofsky is the founding partner of DeBofsky Law, where for more than 40 years he has represented claimants whose disability, life, health, and retirement benefits were denied, both under ERISA and in individual insurance disputes. He has argued cases before federal courts across the country that shaped how ERISA is interpreted, and his firm has roughly 100 appellate decisions to its name.

Live Video-Broadcast: December 21, 2026

2 hour CLE

Tuition: $195.00
Subscribe to Federal Bar Association CLE Pass...
Co-Sponsored by myLawCLE
Get this course, plus over 1,000+ of live webinars.
Learn More
Training 5 or more people?

Sign-up for a law firm subscription plan and each attorney in the firm receives free access to all CLE Programs

Program Summary

 

A single psychiatric label can cut a disability claim off at 24 months

Long-term disability insurers increasingly invoke the 24-month mental-health limitation whenever a file mentions depression, anxiety, or another behavioral-health condition. Courts in the Sixth and Eighth Circuits apply a but-for test, under which the mere presence of a mental condition does not trigger the cap. Elsewhere, deferential review and the plan’s wording can decide the case.

Let a treater’s causation opinion arrive after the limitation notice, and Gill shows a court may discount it. Leave psychiatric labels and reviewer reports unanswered, and Hall shows how a brain-injury claim is lost. Overlook the insurer’s own reinstatement letter, and McEachin shows you have missed evidence of when the clock started. Plead the case in psychiatric terms, and you may concede the limitation before the court reads the record.

You walk out with intake checklists, template letters to treating providers, and a response matrix for reviewer reports. You also get a decision tree for the standard of review and the clock arguments, and a complaint and brief checklist. These are claimant-side judgment calls the case law alone does not make for you.

Key topics to be discussed:

  • Setting the Proof Target
    How but-for causation and the plan’s wording set the proof target, and what Gill, Hall, and Krash show about late opinions, psychiatric labels, and unanswered reviewers.
  • Intake and Treater Opinions
    How to sequence intake to avoid the diagnosis-labeling trap, and how to obtain treating-provider causation opinions and Attending Physician Statements that hold up.
  • Testing and the Physical Record
    How neuropsychological testing, functional capacity evaluations, and occupational evidence support physical causation, and how to date the physical record through continuous treatment and the carrier’s own letters.
  • Reviewer Reports and SSDI
    How to demand and rebut reviewer reports under 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(4) inside the appeal window, and how a parallel SSDI claim and its offset fit the plan.
  • Reading the Denial and the Plan
    How to read the denial for comorbidity versus etiology, map plan wording and circuit law, and work the standard-of-review fork created by discretionary clauses, state bans, and governing-law clauses.
  • The Clock and the Remedy
    How to sequence never-started and tolling arguments, draft the complaint and opening brief without conceding the psychiatric frame, and choose reinstatement or remand before the fee petition.

This course is co-sponsored with myLawCLE.

Date / Time: December 21, 2026

  • 2:30 pm – 4:40 pm Eastern
  • 1:30 pm – 3:40 pm Central
  • 12:30 pm – 2:40 pm Mountain
  • 11:30 am – 1:40 pm Pacific

Closed-captioning available

Speakers

Mark D. DeBofsky, Founding Partner | DeBofsky Law, Ltd

Mark D. DeBofsky is the founding partner of DeBofsky Law, where for more than 40 years he has represented claimants whose disability, life, health, and retirement benefits were denied, both under ERISA and in individual insurance disputes. He has argued cases before federal courts across the country that shaped how ERISA is interpreted, and his firm has roughly 100 appellate decisions to its name.

  • Education & Credentials

He earned his J.D. from the University of Illinois College of Law in 1980 and his B.A. from the University of Michigan in 1977, and he was admitted in Illinois in 1980. He served as an adjunct professor of law at the University of Illinois Chicago School of Law (formerly The John Marshall Law School) from 2000 to 2022.

  • Recognition & Leadership

He received a three-year appointment to the U.S. Department of Labor’s ERISA Advisory Council, where he served on the drafting team for the Council’s December 2023 report on long-term disability benefits and mental health disparity, after serving on an Illinois task force convened under Governor J.B. Pritzker to study mental health parity in disability insurance. He has been recognized as a Super Lawyer in Employee Benefits/ERISA since 2009, is AV Preeminent rated by Martindale-Hubbell, has been ranked among the top five percent of Illinois attorneys in disability, employee benefits, and ERISA law by the Leading Lawyers Network, and was a 2008 finalist for LexisNexis’ Insurance Law Center Policyholder Attorney of the Year.

  • Professional Involvement

He co-authored, with Mayoung Nham, an American Bar Association Section of Labor and Employment Law article on the Advisory Council’s mental health disparity report, and he has written widely on disability claims, including a 2023 article urging disability insurers to end discrimination against mental health conditions and a Chicago Daily Law Bulletin column on why disability benefits turn on symptoms rather than diagnosis. He lectures frequently on ERISA and disability insurance, including programs for the American Bar Association, the Illinois Trial Lawyers Association, and Chicago-Kent College of Law, and is a member of the Chicago Bar Association.

  • Experience

His practice covers ERISA long-term disability, life, health, and long-term care claims and retirement plan disputes, from the administrative appeal through federal litigation and appeal. He recently served as co-counsel in a $27.5 million ERISA class action settlement on behalf of approximately 8,500 United Airlines retirees.

Agenda

SESSION 1 – Building the Physical-Causation Record for LTD Claims Facing the Mental-Health Limitation | Mark D. DeBofsky | 2:30pm – 3:30pm

Long-term disability insurers increasingly invoke the 24-month mental-health limitation whenever a claim file mentions depression, anxiety, or another behavioral-health condition. This session shows claimant-side ERISA counsel how to build the claim and appeal record that keeps benefits flowing past that limit through proof of physical causation. It covers setting the proof target under but-for causation and the plan’s wording, and the lessons of losses such as Gill, Hall, and Krash. It then walks through intake sequencing and the diagnosis-labeling trap, treating-provider causation opinions, neuropsychological testing and functional capacity evaluations, and dating the physical record. The session closes with answering reservation letters and reviewer reports inside the appeal window, and running an SSDI claim in parallel.

BREAK | 3:30pm – 3:40pm

SESSION 2 – Litigating the 24-Month Mental-Health Limitation on the Claimant’s Side in Federal Court | Mark D. DeBofsky | 3:40pm – 4:40pm

Once the administrative record closes, the fight over the mental-health limitation moves to federal court. This session covers how to read the denial letter for comorbidity, a separate disabling physical condition, versus etiology, a mental condition caused by physical injury. It addresses how plan wording and circuit law under McEachin, Weyer, Hall, and Gill shape causation and burden, and how discretionary clauses, state bans, and governing-law clauses decide the standard of review. Attendees will learn how to sequence the arguments that the limitation clock never started and that it was tolled, draft the complaint and opening brief without conceding the psychiatric frame, and choose between reinstatement and remand before filing the fee petition.

Credits

Alaska

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.
Alabama

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Arkansas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Arizona

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

California

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Colorado

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Connecticut

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

District of Columbia

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Delaware

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Florida

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 General Hours

Receive CLE credit in Florida via attorney submission.
Georgia

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Hawaii

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Iowa

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Idaho

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Illinois

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Indiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Kansas

Pending CLE Approval
2 Substantive

Kentucky

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Louisiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Massachusetts

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maryland

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maine

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Michigan

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Minnesota

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Missouri

Approved for CLE Credits
2.4 General

Mississippi

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Montana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Dakota

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14
Nebraska

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.
New Hampshire

Approved for CLE Credits
120 General minutes

As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.
New Jersey

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2
New Mexico

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Nevada

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

New York

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.
Ohio

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Oklahoma

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

Oregon

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Pennsylvania

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Rhode Island

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

South Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

South Dakota

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Tennessee

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Texas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Utah

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Virginia

Not Eligible
2 General Hours

Vermont

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Washington

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 Law & Legal Hours

Receive CLE credit in Washington via attorney submission.
Wisconsin

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

West Virginia

Pending CLE Approval
2.4 General

Wyoming

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

More CLE Webinars
Upcoming CLE Webinars
AI-Augmented Legal Workflows: A Map to Success
AI-Augmented Legal Workflows: A Map to Success Thu, November 19, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay
Using Adobe Acrobat’s AI Assistant for Legal
Using Adobe Acrobat’s AI Assistant for Legal Fri, November 20, 2026
Live Webcast
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition)
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition) Tue, November 24, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay