Nonprofit Board Counsel: Building the Record That Survives Member Suits and Attorney General Demands

Anita L. Pelletier
Anita L. Pelletier
Nixon Peabody LLP

Anita L. Pelletier is Counsel in the Nonprofit practice of Nixon Peabody LLP, based in Rochester, where she advises nonprofit organizations on the legal requirements and best practices that apply to their governance and operations.

Jack R. Bierig
Jack R. Bierig
ArentFox Schiff

Jack R. Bierig is Counsel in the Chicago office of ArentFox Schiff, where his practice centers on the general representation of associations.

Live Video-Broadcast: December 14, 2026

2 hour CLE

Tuition: $195.00
Subscribe to Federal Bar Association CLE Pass...
Co-Sponsored by myLawCLE
Get this course, plus over 1,000+ of live webinars.
Learn More
Training 5 or more people?

Sign-up for a law firm subscription plan and each attorney in the firm receives free access to all CLE Programs

Program Summary

Your Board’s Record Is Written Before the Subpoena Arrives

State attorneys general are serving subpoenas on nonprofits while boards face member demands and conflict-of-interest transactions. In First Choice v. Platkin, the Attorney General of New Jersey sought the identity of all contributors to a nonprofit. This past term, the Supreme Court held that First Choice could go to federal court to have the subpoena enjoined. Where to fight is now a decision for board counsel.

Approve a conflict-of-interest transaction, and you answer to state conflict requirements and Code Section 4958. Receive a federal subpoena, and the nonprofit has two weeks under Rule 45 to object. Notify the insurer of a subpoena, and next year’s premium could increase. File an anti-SLAPP motion, and discovery is stayed in most jurisdictions. Lose that motion, and some states award attorneys’ fees to the plaintiff.

Leave able to document conflict approvals by eligible directors and respond to member demands. Leave able to issue a litigation hold, narrow a subpoena’s scope, and choose between state and federal court. A case study, American Academy of Pediatrics v. Uthmeier, tests each call against a real lawsuit. These are judgment calls made with incomplete facts, not doctrine you can look up.

Key topics to be discussed:

  • Fiduciary Duty Mapping

How the duties of care, loyalty, and obedience, the question of who those duties are owed to, and the Goldklang case shape the advice you give a nonprofit board of directors.

  • Conflict Transaction Approval

How disclosure and recusal, approval by eligible directors, and documentation carry a conflict-of-interest transaction through state conflict requirements, New York in particular, and Code Section 4958.

  • Member Demands and Rights

How member eligibility, voting rights, inspections, record dates, and member records govern a demand to amend the bylaws or to appoint or remove directors, and how a Membership Agreement and Code of Conduct support member discipline and removal.

  • Subpoena Response Strategy

How the issuing court, the two-week objection period under Rule 45, personal jurisdiction, and scope negotiation drive the response, along with the litigation hold, document retention policy, Board member documents, and insurer notification.

  • First Amendment Forum Choices

How First Choice v. Platkin lets a nonprofit ask a federal court to enjoin a state subpoena, where that route is less clear, and when removal, a motion to dismiss, or an anti-SLAPP motion answers a lawsuit.

  • Lawsuit Defense Decisions

How insurer notice, the litigation hold, motions to dismiss, the dismissal and joint representation of Board member defendants, and the lessons of American Academy of Pediatrics v. Uthmeier set the first moves after a complaint.

This course is co-sponsored with myLawCLE.

Date / Time: December 14, 2026

  • 12:00 pm – 2:10 pm Eastern
  • 11:00 am – 1:10 pm Central
  • 10:00 am – 12:10 pm Mountain
  • 11:00 am – 11:10 am Pacific

Closed-captioning available

Speakers

Anita L. Pelletier, Counsel | Nixon Peabody LLP

Anita L. Pelletier is Counsel in the Nonprofit practice of Nixon Peabody LLP, based in Rochester, where she advises nonprofit organizations on the legal requirements and best practices that apply to their governance and operations. Nonprofit corporate governance and board disputes are a focus of her practice, and she has helped organizations of all sizes update their bylaws and policies.

  • Education & Credentials

Ms. Pelletier earned her JD, summa cum laude, from Syracuse University College of Law. She also holds an MPA from the Maxwell School of Public Administration and a BA in Economics from St. John Fisher College. She is admitted to practice in New York and Massachusetts.

  • Recognition & Leadership

Ms. Pelletier is listed in the 2027 edition of The Best Lawyers in America for Nonprofit/Charities Law and has been listed since 2017. Lawyers Alliance for New York named her a Cornerstone Awards Honoree in 2023. She was a 2024 Rochester Business Journal “Women of Excellence” honoree and received The Daily Record’s Excellence in Law, Top Women in Law Award in 2019 and its Up & Coming Attorneys Award in 2007.
Her pro bono work has been recognized with the New York State Bar Association Pro Bono Service Award for the Seventh Judicial District (2018), the Women’s Bar Association of the State of New York Hanna S. Cohn Pro Bono Award (2012), the Legal Aid Society of New York City Pro Bono Award (2005), and Nixon Peabody’s Rodman Peabody Pro Bono Award (2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2011). She is a 2026 Nixon Peabody Pro Bono Champion. The Monroe County Bar Association presented her with its President’s Award in 2016 and its William E. McKnight Award in 2003.

  • Professional Involvement

Ms. Pelletier has served on nonprofit boards herself, as a former board member of the YWCA of Rochester and of the Greater Rochester Association of Women Attorneys, where she also chaired the Media Committee and co-chaired the Program Committee. She is a former member of the Legal Resources Committee of the National Association of College and University Attorneys and a member of the American, New York State, and Monroe County bar associations.
She presents regularly on nonprofit governance. Her programs include “Good Governance for 501(c)(3) Organizations” (MyLawCLE, October 31, 2023), “IRS Guidelines for Good Governance for 501(c)(3) Organizations” (Lorman Education Services, February 2019 and August 2019), and “Non-Profits Law 101: Governance, Board Functions, Compliance, and Employment Issues Within Charities” (Federal Bar Association, July 2021). She wrote “New York Nonprofit Revitalization Act – What Does It Mean for the Local Volunteer Fire Companies?” for The Volunteer Firefighter (FASNY, September 2014). In her community, she is a USA Swimming Official with Niagara Swimming and has volunteered as a referee for fifteen years.

  • Experience

Ms. Pelletier’s governance work responds to closer scrutiny of nonprofits by the IRS, state charity regulators, and the public. She works with nonprofits on internal compliance reviews and on strategies to address weaknesses before a regulator makes contact, and she most recently helped a nonprofit conduct an internal compliance review covering IRS and nonprofit governance requirements. She has guided organizations through audits and investigations by the IRS and state charity regulators.
Her transactional work includes sales of assets, mergers, and dissolutions, including the state charity-approval process. Most recently she has handled affiliation transactions in which one nonprofit became the sole member of another, along with asset transfers and nonprofit mergers. She also advises charities on charitable solicitation rules for social media and electronic communications and has represented businesses on sales promotions, including commercial co-venture promotions, sweepstakes, and contests.

 

Jack R. Bierig, Counsel | ArentFox Schiff

Jack R. Bierig is Counsel in the Chicago office of ArentFox Schiff, where his practice centers on the general representation of associations. He has represented many clients in government antitrust and health fraud investigations, in actions brought by the US Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission, and in private antitrust litigation. His work for associations also spans antitrust counseling, health care regulatory issues, copyright, trademark and trade secret matters, and FDA regulation.

  • Education & Credentials

Mr. Bierig received his JD from Harvard Law School in 1972 and his AB in History from Brandeis University in 1968, where he was elected to Phi Beta Kappa. He is a member of the Illinois Bar and is admitted to practice before the US Supreme Court; the US Courts of Appeals for the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th, 6th, 7th, 9th, 11th, and District of Columbia Circuits; and the Trial Bar of the US District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.
He teaches Health Law and Policy and Food and Drug Law and Policy at the University of Chicago Law School and at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy.

  • Recognition & Leadership

Best Lawyers named Mr. Bierig its 2019 “Lawyer of the Year” for Nonprofit/Charities Law in Chicago, and The Legal 500 US recognized him in the Not-for-Profit category from 2014 to 2017. He has been listed in The Best Lawyers in America from 1995 through 2027 and ranked by Chambers USA for Antitrust (2012–2017, 2019–2021, 2023–2026). Other honors include BTI Client Service All-Stars for Antitrust (2015), Illinois Super Lawyers (2020–2021), Illinois Leading Lawyer (2021), and Best Lawyers in America Lawyer of the Year for Chicago Health Care (2011).
His leadership roles sit largely within the association and nonprofit community. He is a former Chair of the Legal Section Council of the American Society of Association Executives, a former President of the Illinois Association of Healthcare Attorneys, and the Founder and a Past President of the Center for Conflict Resolution. He is also a Past President of Jewish Vocational Service.

  • Professional Involvement

Mr. Bierig is a member of the Legal Section of the American Society of Association Executives, the Illinois Association of Healthcare Attorneys, and the American Bar Association, and he formerly served on the Board of Governors of the Chicago Bar Association. He serves as a Board Member of Selfhelp Home, as Vice Chair of the Advisory Committee of the University of Chicago Institute for Molecular Engineering, and as Secretary of the Standard Club.
He speaks frequently at industry and university conferences on antitrust, association law, and health care regulatory issues. His articles have appeared in Antitrust Health Care Chronicle, The Health Lawyer, Pathologist, the American Bar Association Journal, the Loyola Law Journal, and the St. Louis University Law Journal, and he contributed the chapter “Antitrust for Physicians” to the Physician’s Survival Guide, jointly published by the American Medical Association and the National Health Lawyers Association.

  • Experience

Mr. Bierig’s association clients include the American Medical Association, the American Dental Association, the American Optometric Association, the National Association of REALTORS®, the Federation of State Medical Boards, the American Board of Medical Specialties, the American Academy of Periodontology, the American Association of Endodontists, the American Veterinary Medical Association, the American Health Information Management Association, and the Greater Las Vegas Association of REALTORS®. He advises certifying boards, including the American Board of Dermatology, the American Board of Emergency Medicine, and the American Board of Periodontology, and represents accreditation organizations, including the Liaison Committee on Medical Education, ARC-PA, and CoARC.
In litigation, his clients have prevailed in several high-profile defamation actions, and he has won several victories for real estate associations in antitrust challenges to their policies on access to multiple listing services. He represented the American Medical Association and the American Dental Association in cases challenging copyright in their nomenclature works.

Agenda

SESSION 1 – Advising Nonprofit Boards on Conflicted Transactions and Internal Member and Director Disputes | Anita L. Pelletier | 12:00pm – 1:00pm

Effective nonprofit governance requires a clear understanding of directors’ obligations and members’ rights, especially in difficult situations such as conflict-of-interest transactions and member disputes. This CLE will examine the fiduciary duties of nonprofit directors, to whom those duties are owed, and conflicts of interest. The program will also explore nonprofit membership, including eligibility, rights and general best practices. Attendees will gain practical guidance for responding to member demands and implementing sound governance practices.

BREAK | 1:00pm – 1:10pm

SESSION 2 – Responses by Non-Profits to Subpoenas and Lawsuits | Jack R. Bierig | 1:10pm – 2:10pm

This session covers how a non-profit should respond to subpoenas and lawsuits. The response to a subpoena depends on whether it is issued out of a federal court or a state court and whether it raises First Amendment or federal constitutional issues. The session will address objections under Rule 45 of the Federal Rules, personal jurisdiction, agreements to reduce the scope of a subpoena, and federal injunctions against state court subpoenas after First Choice v. Platkin. It will also cover document retention policies, litigation holds, documents of Board members, and whether to notify the insurer. For lawsuits, the session will examine insurer notice and choice of counsel, motions to dismiss, removal to federal court, anti-SLAPP motions, and complaints that name Board members as defendants, including indemnification and joint representation. It closes with a case study, American Academy of Pediatrics v. Uthmeier, and the lessons of that case.

Credits

Alaska

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.
Alabama

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Arkansas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Arizona

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

California

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Colorado

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Connecticut

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

District of Columbia

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Delaware

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Florida

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 General Hours

Receive CLE credit in Florida via attorney submission.
Georgia

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Hawaii

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Iowa

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Idaho

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Illinois

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Indiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Kansas

Pending CLE Approval
2 Substantive

Kentucky

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Louisiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Massachusetts

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maryland

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maine

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Michigan

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Minnesota

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Missouri

Approved for CLE Credits
2.4 General

Mississippi

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Montana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Dakota

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14
Nebraska

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.
New Hampshire

Approved for CLE Credits
120 General minutes

As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.
New Jersey

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2
New Mexico

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Nevada

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

New York

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.
Ohio

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Oklahoma

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

Oregon

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Pennsylvania

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Rhode Island

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

South Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

South Dakota

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Tennessee

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Texas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Utah

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Virginia

Not Eligible
2 General Hours

Vermont

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Washington

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 Law & Legal Hours

Receive CLE credit in Washington via attorney submission.
Wisconsin

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

West Virginia

Pending CLE Approval
2.4 General

Wyoming

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

More CLE Webinars
Upcoming CLE Webinars
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition)
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition) Tue, November 24, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay
False Claims Act Hot Topics (2026 Edition)
False Claims Act Hot Topics (2026 Edition) Tue, December 1, 2026
Live Webcast
HIPAA Privacy, Security and AI – Oh My!
HIPAA Privacy, Security and AI – Oh My! Tue, December 1, 2026
Live Webcast
Mini-Med School Orthopedic Trauma Edition
Mini-Med School Orthopedic Trauma Edition Thu, December 3, 2026
Live Webcast