Pore Space Is Property: The Landowner’s Case Against Carbon Storage Forced Amalgamation

Ralph C. Thomas III
Ralph C. Thomas III
Whiteford, Taylor & Preston LLP

Ralph C. Thomas III is Senior Counsel and Government Contracts Practice Lead in the Washington, D.C. office of Whiteford, Taylor & Preston LLP, with substantial experience in all phases of government contracts law.

Olivia L. Lynch
Olivia L. Lynch
Crowell & Moring LLP

Olivia L. Lynch is a partner in Crowell & Moring's Government Contracts Group in the Washington, D.C. office, where she advises government contractors on the procurement process, compliance and ethics, commercial item contracting, accessibility, supply chain assurance, and state and local procurement law.

On-Demand: November 16, 2026

2 hour CLE

Tuition: $195.00
Subscribe to Federal Bar Association CLE Pass...
Co-Sponsored by myLawCLE
Get this course, plus over 1,000+ of live webinars.
Learn More
Training 5 or more people?

Sign-up for a law firm subscription plan and each attorney in the firm receives free access to all CLE Programs

Program Summary

 

Federal Frameworks Are Redrawing Private Rights on Two Fronts

Federal incentives and federal rules are redrawing private rights on two fronts at once. Carbon-storage tax credits drive developers to assemble vast subsurface reservoirs, and state amalgamation statutes now bind the unwilling landowner once a consent threshold is reached. Meanwhile, the SBA's proposed 2026 size standards are forcing federal contractors and their counsel to re-examine affiliation exposure and teaming structures — often in the middle of active procurements.

Miss a severance or reservation in the title, and the wrong owner consents or gets paid. Accept the statutory payment formula, and the constitutional measure goes unargued. Ignore Cedar Point and Loretto, and permanent storage looks like regulation, not occupation. Structure the teaming agreement loosely, and the ostensible subcontractor rule converts it into affiliation. Lose the size protest, and the award goes with it.

Attendees walk out with a map of the pore space ownership rules, a takings-claim framework adapted to compelled storage, a repeatable framework for mapping affiliation risk, and a drafting checklist for teaming and joint venture documents that survive size and eligibility protests. Practitioner judgment on both fronts, from counsel who work exactly this ground.

Key topics to be discussed:

  • Pore Space Ownership
    How the surface-estate majority rule, severances, and reservations decide who must consent to storage and who gets paid.
  • Forced Amalgamation and Takings
    How consent thresholds bind nonconsenting owners, and how Cedar Point, Loretto, and the Kelo public-use question frame compelled storage.
  • Landowner Litigation Toolkit
    How plume trespass, inverse condemnation, and administrative appeals get landowners into court, and which ripeness traps to avoid.
  • Affiliation Under the Proposed Size Standards
    How the SBA's proposed 2026 size standards reshape affiliation analysis under 13 C.F.R. § 121.103, often mid-procurement.
  • Ostensible Subcontractor and Pass-Through Risk
    How teaming and subcontract structures convert into affiliation findings, and the structuring decisions that prevent it.
  • Drafting the Teaming Agreement
    How to paper teaming agreements and joint ventures that survive size and eligibility protests, from workshare and control terms to the mentor-protégé rules.

This course is co-sponsored with myLawCLE.

Closed-captioning available

Speakers

Ralph C. Thomas III, Senior Counsel | Whiteford, Taylor & Preston LLP

Ralph C. Thomas III is Senior Counsel and Government Contracts Practice Lead in the Washington, D.C. office of Whiteford, Taylor & Preston LLP, with substantial experience in all phases of government contracts law. He has represented government contractors before federal courts, federal agencies, and arbitration tribunals in contract terminations, bid protests, size protests, contract claims, and dispute resolution, and he advises firm teams on government contracts issues arising in mergers and acquisitions and corporate structuring. He is especially well suited to this program: 13 years leading NASA’s Small and Disadvantaged Business Utilization Office, extensive drafting of joint venture, subcontract, and teaming agreements, and size protest work before federal agencies, bringing the perspective of a former federal senior executive who now structures these agreements in private practice.

  • Education & Credentials

Mr. Thomas received his J.D. from Harvard Law School in 1978 and his B.A. from the University of California at Berkeley in 1975. He is admitted in the District of Columbia and is a UK Solicitor admitted to the Senior Courts of England and Wales. He is also admitted before the U.S. Supreme Court, the D.C., Federal, and Armed Forces Circuits, the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, and the U.S. Court of International Trade, among other federal courts.

  • Recognition & Leadership

The District of Columbia Bar named Mr. Thomas its 2025 Lawyer of the Year in Government Contracts, and the Federal Bar Association presented him its 2025 Outstanding Section and Division Leader Award as Chair of its Government Contracts Section. His government service earned him the Presidential Rank of Distinguished Executive, awarded to roughly one percent of federal Senior Executives, and the Presidential Rank of Meritorious Executive, awarded to five percent. A military veteran, he served four years in the U.S. Air Force and achieved the rank of Staff Sergeant.

  • Professional Involvement

Mr. Thomas is Vice-Chair of the Small Business and Other Socioeconomic Programs Committee of the ABA’s Public Contract Law Section and a member of the District of Columbia Bar, the U.K. Procurement Lawyers Association, and the London Court of International Arbitration. He taught Government Contracts Law at the University of Virginia, spent five years as an Adjunct Professor of Law in the LL.M. program at Concord School of Law, and has published more than 80 articles on government contracts.

  • Experience

For 13 years, Mr. Thomas served as Associate Administrator of NASA’s award-winning Small and Disadvantaged Business Utilization Office. He has testified before Congress more than 30 times on issues facing small government contractors and was an invited panelist at the 2023 White House Contract Summit. In private practice he has drafted and reviewed numerous joint venture, subcontract, and teaming agreements, including cross-border agreements involving UK companies.

 

Olivia L. Lynch, Partner | Crowell & Moring LLP

Olivia L. Lynch is a partner in Crowell & Moring’s Government Contracts Group in the Washington, D.C. office, where she advises government contractors on the procurement process, compliance and ethics, commercial item contracting, accessibility, supply chain assurance, and state and local procurement law. She maintains an active bid protest docket and counsels large and small contractors on small business issues in procurements, protests, transactions, investigations, disclosures, and False Claims Act litigation. She is especially well suited to this program: advice on small business size and status certifications and SBA mentor-protégé programs, compliance counseling on the limitation on subcontracting, and size protests and appeals before the SBA’s Office of Hearings and Appeals, bringing the perspective of a government contracts litigator who handles the eligibility questions teaming arrangements raise.

  • Education & Credentials

Ms. Lynch earned her J.D. from Georgetown University Law Center and her B.S.F.S. in international economics from the Georgetown University School of Foreign Service. While in law school, she externed for Judge Thomas Wheeler at the U.S. Court of Federal Claims. She is admitted in the District of Columbia and New York and before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.

  • Professional Involvement

Ms. Lynch presented Crowell & Moring’s March 2026 webinar on ongoing government audits of small business programs and their impact on both large and small contractors. She currently volunteers for the DC Volunteer Lawyers Project’s Protection Assistance Project, has represented incarcerated D.C. residents seeking parole and compassionate release, and has volunteered for legal service organizations representing survivors of domestic and sexual violence.

  • Experience

Ms. Lynch has handled agency-level bid protests and protests before the Government Accountability Office, the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, and the FAA’s Office of Dispute Resolution for Acquisition, representing both protesters and awardees in pre-award challenges, cancellations, sole source awards, competitive range exclusions, and post-award disputes. She has filed and defended against size protests, litigated size appeals before the SBA’s Office of Hearings and Appeals, and advised on Paycheck Protection Program eligibility and related investigations, including the defense of family-owned staffing companies in a Southern District of Texas qui tam suit in which the court granted summary judgment.

Agenda

SESSION 1 – Advising Federal Contractors on Affiliation Under the Proposed 2026 Size Standards | Olivia L. Lynch | 2:30pm – 3:30pm

This session examines the property fight underneath the carbon capture boom: as federal tax incentives drive storage developers to assemble vast subsurface reservoirs, state amalgamation and unitization statutes increasingly allow projects to proceed over the objection of unwilling landowners — and the question of what those landowners are owed has become the next great takings battleground. Attorneys will learn the property foundation first: who owns pore space, the majority rule vesting it in the surface estate, the state statutes that have codified that ownership, and the severance and conveyancing questions that complicate every title examination; the forced amalgamation architecture — the statutes that let a storage operator bind nonconsenting owners once a consent threshold is reached, the administrative findings they require, and how they differ from the oil-and-gas unitization tradition they borrowed from; the constitutional case against compelled inclusion, including physical-occupation takings doctrine after Cedar Point and Loretto, the public-use question when the taker is a private storage developer, and the just compensation measure for a resource with no established market; and the landowner’s litigation toolkit — trespass theories for migrating CO2 plumes, inverse condemnation, and the procedural paths into state and federal court. Attendees will leave with a map of the ownership rules, a takings-claim framework adapted to compelled storage, and the landowner-side perspective this debate has so far mostly lacked.

BREAK | 3:30pm – 3:40pm

SESSION 2 – Structuring Teaming Agreements and Joint Ventures Against Ostensible Subcontractor and Pass-Through Risk | Ralph C. Thomas III | 3:40pm – 4:40pm

This session moves to the federal contracting front: structuring teaming agreements and joint ventures that can withstand ostensible subcontractor and pass-through challenges. Attorneys will learn how affiliation is determined under 13 C.F.R. § 121.103 and how the SBA’s proposed 2026 size standards change that analysis, often in the middle of active procurements; the ostensible subcontractor rule and the fact patterns that convert a teaming relationship into affiliation; the structuring and drafting decisions — workshare, management, control, and mentor-protégé terms — that determine whether an agreement survives a size or eligibility protest; and how disputes actually unfold, from SBA size determinations through Office of Hearings and Appeals review. Attendees will leave with a repeatable framework for mapping affiliation risk under both current and proposed size standards and a drafting checklist for teaming and joint venture documents — taught by counsel who spent 13 years inside the federal contracting establishment and now structures these agreements in private practice.

Credits

Alaska

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through Alaska’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity.
Alabama

Approved for Self-Study Credits
2 General

Arkansas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Arizona

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

California

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Colorado

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Connecticut

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

District of Columbia

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Delaware

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Florida

Pending CLE Approval
2 General Hours

Receive CLE credit in Florida via attorney submission.
Georgia

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Hawaii

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Iowa

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Idaho

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Illinois

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Indiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Kansas

Pending CLE Approval
2 Substantive

Kentucky

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Louisiana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Massachusetts

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maryland

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Maine

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Michigan

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Minnesota

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Missouri

Approved for Self-Study Credits
2.4 General

Mississippi

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Montana

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

North Dakota

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through North Dakota’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity. Section 1, Policy 1.14
Nebraska

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

myLawCLE reports attendance to Nebraska on each attorney’s behalf for all programs. Please do not self-report.
New Hampshire

Approved for CLE Credits
120 General minutes

As of July 1, 2014, the NHMCLE Board no longer provides pre- or post-approval of courses. Attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance online at www.nhbar.org, based on qualification provisions of Rule 53.
New Jersey

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New Jersey’s recognition of multi-jurisdictional reciprocity, except for the courses required under BCLE Reg. 201:2
New Mexico

Approved for Self-Study Credits
2 General

Nevada

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

New York

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Our programs are CLE-eligible through New York’s Approved Jurisdiction Group “B”.
Ohio

Approved for Self-Study Credits
2 General

Oklahoma

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Oregon

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Pennsylvania

Approved for Self-Study Credits
2 General

Rhode Island

Pending CLE Approval
2.5 General

South Carolina

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

South Dakota

No MCLE Required
2 CLE Hour(s)

Tennessee

Approved for Self-Study Credits
2 General

Texas

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Utah

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

Virginia

Not Eligible
2 General Hours

Vermont

Approved for CLE Credits
2 General

Washington

Approved via Attorney Submission
2 Law & Legal Hours

Receive CLE credit in Washington via attorney submission.
Wisconsin

Approved for Self-Study Credits
2 General

West Virginia

Pending CLE Approval
2.4 General

Wyoming

Pending CLE Approval
2 General

More CLE Webinars
Upcoming CLE Webinars
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition)
Obtaining and Using Social Media Evidence (2026 Edition) Tue, November 24, 2026
On-Demand
Live Replay
False Claims Act Hot Topics (2026 Edition)
False Claims Act Hot Topics (2026 Edition) Tue, December 1, 2026
Live Webcast
HIPAA Privacy, Security and AI – Oh My!
HIPAA Privacy, Security and AI – Oh My! Tue, December 1, 2026
Live Webcast
Mini-Med School Orthopedic Trauma Edition
Mini-Med School Orthopedic Trauma Edition Thu, December 3, 2026
Live Webcast